WHY THE
G8 WILL NOT MAKE POVERTY HISTORY
During my
7 hour journey to Edinburgh last Friday I passed the time by
reading the heart rending true stories of womens lives over
several decades in China in the book "The Good Women of
China" by Xinran. This is a book I believe we should all
read to gain an understanding of the appalling depths to which
men can descend in their treatment of women. A
Chinese campaign group at the Edinburgh gathering also made
me aware that between 65 and 80 million people in China have
died at the hands of the Chinese Communist Party since it came
to power. Many are now courageously leaving the Party, despite
the penalties this will incur.
But why is China so relevant to the deliberations taking place
at the G8 meetings and the central issues of poverty in Africa
and global warming?
The answers to this question are to be found in China's economic
growth and its new trade with corrupt and repressive regimes
in Africa. China is building new alliances and stealing a march
on the West in its take up of the neo liberal privatisation
agenda being promoted by Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. The drive
towards globalisation is now likely to be led by China with
India and Russia following closely behind.
In Sierra Leone, for example, which I have visited several times
in connection with poverty alleviation projects, China plans
to turn the beautiful Lumley beach near Freetown into a holiday
complex for rich tourists (During the Cold War China built the
national stadium and swimming pool). There seems little doubt
that poor people will then be excluded from this public amenity.
China is now the main obstacle to stopping the genocide in Darfur
(60 % of Sudan's oil now flows to China) as it will not agree
to any moves to bring Sudan's leaders before the International
Court to stand trial for genocide, nor to sending in troops.
Over several centuries the rich resources (including food crops,
and its people) have been stolen from a now impoverished continent.
With China now set to join the exploiters of the West I find
it impossible to feel positive about anything that is likely
to come out of the G8 meetings. I don't doubt Gordon Brown's
and Bob Geldoff's good intentions, but I fail to see how the
failed free market, privatisation, neo-liberal policies of the
past are going to help the poorest people of Africa. And yet
these are precisely the conditions being imposed on poor countries
as the price they must pay for debt relief. Also I fail to see
that 'free' trade, whether it is supposedly 'fair' or not, is
going to benefit the poor to any substantial degree. Africa
is a rich continent which, with a little aid to compensate for
the debt the West already owes for the exploitation of the past,
will be able to restrict its trade to countries within its own
borders.
The rich, generally corrupt, leaders of Africa will increasingly
turn to China, not the West, to fuel economic growth and perhaps
as a result, a bit more of the wealth created will trickle down
to the poor - but I have my doubts.
However, perhaps the Chinese will realise that gross inequality
fuels wars which could affect its own economic interests and
it will therefore help Africa to build up a greater capacity
to produce finished goods rather than depend on the sale of
cash crops and raw materials for a pittance.
And how will all this growth affect climate change? China derives
90% of its electricity from coal. China has 30,000 coal mines
and uses one third of the world's total. Well if, in 20 years
time, China has as many affluent consumers as there are in the
West, then this question does not bear thinking about?
We in the West cannot expect China to hold back on its economic
growth unless we change the way we live. The problem of global
warming is currently mainly due to consumption in the USA, Europe,
Australia and Japan. There is an urgent need for planned global
economic decline and a fairer distribution of resources. This
necessarily means that UK consumers must move towards a simpler
lifestyle that does not involve car ownership, for example,
nor long holiday trips abroad.
Mike Thomas
Future in
Our Hands